Crafted for Your Comfort

Handmade Amish Mattresses

Special Offer  20% OFF All Mattresses

Don't Settle For Sleepless nights.

Sleep Better. Live Better.

Investing in a quality mattress is an investment in yourself. Wake up each day feeling refreshed and energized, ready to tackle your day with increased productivity and clarity.

Boost your mood, enrich relationships, and make healthier choices with ease. Elevate your lifestyle with the right mattress; it's more than just sleep – it's your foundation for success.

Shop All Mattresses

You deserve a good night's rest

Experience Amish Quality & Comfort


Call for more information (419) 758-3247

Our single-sided mattresses are built from the support core upward, adding comfort layers as we build upwards toward the topmost quilted cover. This basic mattress is a handcrafted single-sided innerspring mattress, padded on one side. The innerspring or super high-density polyurethane core and various combinations of foam layers above the core create a customized firm or plush feel. 

Mattress Features:

  • Available in Twin to California King sizes
  • Extra Heavy 13 Gauge Offset Coil for superior long-term support
  • Highest Quality All Natural Dunlop Foam for long-term comfort and durability
  • Pressure relieving support
  • Lower back support
  • Ideal for allergy sufferers
  • Amish made in the USA
  • Certified for peace of mind

Mattress Specifications:

  • INNERSPRING: 13 gauge
  • INSULATION: 3-Part Insulator,
  • PADDING: Polyurethane Foam 1.5 wt., 1"
  • SIDE SUPPORT: Double Edge Guard Side Supports
  • PILLOWTOP: Polyurethane Foam 1.8 wt., 1/2", Convoluted Foam 1.8 wt., 3"
  • COVER: Quilted to 1-1/4" 1.8 wt. Foam & FR Rayon Fiber,
  • HEIGHT: 10"
  • WARRANTY: 20-Year (13 years prorated)

Top Customer Picks by Comfort

Best All-in-One Mattress

A high-density, moldable foam core allows the Conforma mattress to fit your sleep style with maximum comfort and support. Choose the traditional feel of gel-infused foam or the unique, resilient feel of natural Talalay latex for padding that perfectly suits your best night of sleep.

View Our Best All-in-One Mattress

Best Firm Mattress

The Quiet Night line of mattresses doesn’t have any extra frills, but every stitch and detail is crafted with the same care and quality of our most expensive mattresses. Even those on a budget or looking for something simple can have the legendary Monarch Rest quality and the unparalleled 20-year warranty.

View Our Best Firm Mattress

Best Soft Mattress

The inner support core of the Integrity mattress is made of pocketed steel coils that give independent suspension within the core frame. The textile pockets are fused to each other, allowing the springs to move independently, so there is less side-to-side motion transfer which means less partner disturbance.

View Our Best Soft Mattress


“For superior mattresses and better sleep, we refer our patients to Herron’s. We know... we sleep on their mattresses ourselves!”

Randy L Luderman, DC
William J Weippert Jr., DC

Try Before You Buy

Herron's Exclusive Dream Room

Eliminate buyer’s remorse and come try any Amish-made mattress for up to 4 hours in our exclusive Dream Room. That’s how committed we are to helping you sleep better, helping you get the most value, and helping you enjoy the BEST mattress shopping experience.  You could say we “out care” our competition.


Mattress Guarantee

We believe it is unfair to put all the risk on you, so we’re taking it from you. If after 30 days you don’t LOVE your mattress, Herron’s will gladly give you your money backNo hassles, no questions asked. When you complete a dream room appointment you'll receive a 90 day money back guarantee. Plus, for peace of mind, you receive an unbeatable 20-Year Mattress Warranty.

Mattress Customer Reviews


"I am totally pleased with my amish made mattress. I did not want to get out of bed. I also can't wait to get back in bed at night. It is well worth the price, and when I need a mattress for anyone in the family, I will be in to Herron's!"

Maggie M.


"We love our bed & mattress! I am constantly telling friends, co-workers, even strangers how much we like & recommend your store for great furniture with spectacular quality."

Angela W.


"Best mattress we've ever had. We would highly recommend Herron's mattresses to anyone!"

Michael W.


"These mattresses sleep great and are well worth the money. The best mattress I've ever had. I sleep like a baby!"

Mary C.

Only at Herron’s Better Sleep Gallery

Handmade in the USA

All our mattresses are handmade here in America by the Amish


Our team will carefully deliver and install you new mattress in place for you

No Buyers Remorse

Try your new mattress before you buy in our exclusive dream room

20 Year Warranty

Herron's will warranty any mattress that has an impression of a ½” or more! For 10 years (20 years prorated)

Mattress Donation

We take your old mattress off your hands and donate it to a family in need

Frequently Asked Questions for Mattresses

Of course! Eliminate buyer’s remorse and come try any Amish-made mattress for up to 4 hours in our exclusive Dream Room.

  1. Choose your mattress.
  2. Make a reservation.
  3. Snuggle in! (Up to 4 Hours)
  4. Free 365 Nite “Love It" Guarantee (+ Mattress Warranty)
  5. Peace of Mind.

Qualified buyers can enjoy 12 months same as cash financing on your mattress purchase. Some restrictions apply, see store for details.

Your mattress is carefully delivered to your home and set in place in your room.

Yes. Not only do we take your gently used mattress off your hands, we donate it to a family in need who doesn't have a mattress of their own.

Share details about your shipping policies, item returns, or customer service.

By participating in our 90-Day Money Back Mattress Guarantee, Herron’s Amish Furniture agrees to fully reimburse you for your mattress/mattress set purchase and tax as long as you help us by agreeing to following requirements. This helps us give you the best mattress shopping experience possible:

  • Participate in our Sleep Assessment Questionnaire.
  • Participate in a Dream Room mattress testing appointment for one hour minimum.
  • For couples, both need to participate in Sleep Questionnaire & Dream Room experience.
  • Choose any mattress from our stock.
  • Once in your home, you must provide proper support for the mattress/mattress set.
  • If returned, purchase must be brought back in the same clean condition it was received. Therefore, it is required that a mattress protector be used during the entire 90 days.

All mattresses are 20% off for a limited time. Enjoy 30% off your mattress purchase when bundled with a new bedroom set.

Start Sleeping Better Tonight

  1. Feel the difference for yourself. Discover a personalized mattress experience that aligns with your unique preferences and ensures a restful night's sleep tailored to your comfort needs.

  2. Take it for a test rest. Eliminate buyer’s remorse and come try any Amish-made mattress for up to 4 hours in our exclusive Dream Room. We go beyond the ordinary, offering you the BEST mattress shopping experience to "out care" the competition. Come and discover the difference in a space dedicated to your utmost comfort and satisfaction.

  3. Embrace peaceful rest. The exceptional craftsmanship and personalized comfort of these mattresses are poised to change the way you sleep. Wake up each morning revitalized and ready to conquer the day after sleeping on your new mattress from Herron's Amish Furniture.